Pub.lished Movie Reviews


The Boondock Saints (1999)

Rating: 10/10
Runtime 108 minutes

"The Boondock Saints" is a film that, while divisive among audiences and critics alike, holds a special place in my heart for its unapologetically visceral approach to the concept of vigilante justice. Directed by Troy Duffy, the movie has garnered a cult following over the years, despite its initial lukewarm reception. What sets this film apart for me is its raw and unfiltered take on the moral complexities of taking down villains outside the confines of the law.

At its core, "The Boondock Saints" is a story about two Irish brothers, Connor and Murphy McManus, who embark on a violent crusade against Boston's criminal underworld after a serendipitous turn of events. This premise alone might sound like a straightforward action flick, but what resonates with me is the film's exploration of themes like vigilante justice, brotherhood, and the moral ambiguity of their actions. The McManus brothers don't see themselves as heroes; they are ordinary men pushed to extraordinary lengths, believing they are on a divine mission to rid the world of evil.

One aspect of "The Boondock Saints" that I particularly love is its stylistic choices. The cinematography and the nonlinear narrative structure keep the audience engaged, piecing together the story as it unfolds from various perspectives, including that of the FBI agent Paul Smecker, brilliantly portrayed by Willem Dafoe. Smecker's character adds a fascinating layer to the narrative, as he grapples with his own moral compass while tracking down the brothers.

Moreover, the film's action sequences are nothing short of exhilarating. They're raw, gritty, and sometimes bordering on the absurd, but always in service of the film's larger thematic concerns. The McManus brothers' methods might be extreme, but there's a certain catharsis in watching them dismantle the criminal underworld piece by piece. And the violence not only serves to thrill us, but also forces us to question the morality of doing nothing versus handing out vigilante justice.

Beyond this simple premise, the movie doesn't really offer much of artistic value. The movie starts off with one of the brothers stating that 'everyone is Irish on Saint Patrick's Day,' before proceeding to dismantle the local Russian and Italian mobs with as many guns and bullets as possible. Overall, the movie is morally ambiguous, showing characters who aren't completely good or bad, and asks the question if it is possible for good men to do bad things to bad men and remain good.

For me, this movie is a must-watch, even though it was pretty much panned by critics. Just remember, not every Saint Patrick's Day is a lucky one, especially if you're a Russian or Italian gangster.


"Yeah, it's St. Paddy's Day, everyone's Irish tonight."


Rating: 10/10
Runtime: 108 minutes
IMDB: 8/10 (250k votes)
Rotten Tomatoes: 28%
First Reviewed: 2009-02-21
Last Updated: 2024-09-29

You should not watch The Boondock Saints if... Whats the deal with...
Warning: The following may contain spoilers:

What's the deal with "The Boondock Saints"? I mean, none of the actors were actually Irish. And what's with the casting of Hollywood actors in general? They need someone to play an Irish man? They find someone born in the USA whose grandfather once visited Ireland. Need someone to play an American superhero? That Kiwi from the land of the Hobbits is clearly the perfect choice. Need someone to play a Kiwi? England is close to New Zealand, isn't it? It isn't? Then why do they sound so similar? Or what about Batman. Need an American to play Batman? That English guy with the incomprehensibly Cockney accent? Perfect! It's like, making a movie isn't hard enough. Let's mess with the casting and make it extra hard.


People who loved this movie also loved...
Fight Club (1999)

"The Boondock Saints" and "Fight Club" are gritty, intense films that explore themes of vigilantism, masculinity, and societal disillusionment. They share a similar dark humor and satirical edge that challenges conventional norms and rules. The complex characters, alluring narratives, and high-octane action sequences in both movies provide an engaging viewing experience. The cult-following status of these films indicates a distinct style and storytelling approach that appeals to viewers who appreciate unconventional cinema.

American Beauty (1999)

Both "The Boondock Saints" and "American Beauty" were released in 1999 and they share thematic elements that make them appealing to the same audience. Both films explore the concept of justice and morality in unconventional ways, each presenting characters who, in their own way, rebel against societal norms and expectations. While "The Boondock Saints" is more action-oriented and "American Beauty" is a drama, both films offer complex characters, dark humor, and thought-provoking narratives that challenge preconceptions about right and wrong. Furthermore, both films have become cult classics, admired for their distinctive storytelling styles, making them a must-watch for any cinephile.

Memento (2000)

Connoisseurs of "The Boondock Saints" (1999) will appreciate "Memento" (2000) for its similar dark and gritty atmosphere, complex narrative structure, and compelling character dynamics. Both films offer a unique take on the crime genre, with Memento’s non-linear storytelling and the Saints' vigilante justice providing a fresh perspective on morality and retribution. Additionally, the intense performances, unexpected plot twists, and the exploration of the protagonists' motivations in both films make for a captivating viewing experience.

Reservoir Dogs (1992)

This Quentin Tarantino crime classic could be a good fit for fans of "The Boondock Saints". It tells the story of eight men who carry out a heist that goes terribly wrong. Watch out for the engrossing volley of Tarantino-esque dialogues, strong narrative design, and stunning performances. The movie is much lauded for its innovative take on the heist genre.

Clerks (1994)

"The Boondock Saints" (1999) and "Clerks" (1994) are cult classics celebrated for their unique storytelling, irreverent humor, and memorable dialogue. These films are rooted in the mundane, yet they employ exaggerated scenarios, raw character portrayals, and sharp wit to create engaging narratives. If you appreciate the unconventional narrative of "The Boondock Saints" with its combination of dark humor and intense action, you'll likely enjoy the similarly offbeat humor and deep character exploration found in "Clerks". Both films also share a low-budget, independent film aesthetic, which lends an authentic, gritty feel to their narratives.

Donnie Darko (2001)

"The Boondock Saints" and "Donnie Darko" are cult classics that offer unique, thought-provoking narratives. They are filled with complex characters, dark humor, and striking visuals that challenge conventional storytelling. The Boondock Saints' exploration of vigilante justice and moral ambiguity is mirrored in Donnie Darko's exploration of time travel and mental illness, making both films appealing to viewers who appreciate unconventional plotlines and philosophical undertones. Moreover, both films have a distinctive style and atmosphere that leave a lasting impression.

Kill Bill: Vol. 1 (2003)

"The Boondock Saints" (1999) and "Kill Bill: Vol. 1" (2003) are action-packed films that delve into the themes of vigilante justice, revenge, and morality with a stylistic flair. They feature compelling characters on a mission, engaging in high octane fight sequences and delivering iconic dialogue. The dark humor, intense drama, and well-choreographed violence in both films appeal to the same audience. Moreover, the distinctive visual aesthetics of both directors, Troy Duffy and Quentin Tarantino, provide a cinematic experience that is both entertaining and memorable.

Kill Bill: Vol. 2 (2004)

Enthusiasts of "The Boondock Saints" will love "Kill Bill: Vol. 2" for its similar blend of stylish, over-the-top violence and dark humor. Both films revolve around central characters on a mission of vengeance, and they share a penchant for stunning, choreographed fight scenes. Additionally, the two movies are heavily influenced by genre cinema, with "The Boondock Saints" drawing inspiration from crime thrillers and "Kill Bill: Vol. 2" paying homage to martial arts and spaghetti westerns. Moreover, each film exhibits a unique narrative structure that keeps viewers engaged right through to their climactic finales.

Office Space (1999)

Though vastly different in genre, both "The Boondock Saints" (1999) and "Office Space" (1999) are cult classics that showcase unconventional and rebellious protagonists challenging their respective systems. "The Boondock Saints" is a darkly comedic action thriller about two brothers taking law into their own hands, while "Office Space" is a workplace satire where disgruntled employees plot against their oppressive corporation. Buffs of "The Boondock Saints" will appreciate "Office Space" for its similar themes of rebellion, humorous dialogue, and memorable characters, even if the setting and tone are different.

Sin City (2005)

Both "The Boondock Saints" and "Sin City" are films that embody gritty, high-octane violence with a distinctive stylized presentation. They offer visually striking cinematic experiences combined with dark, complex narratives and memorable, morally ambiguous characters. Both movies have a unique approach to storytelling, with "The Boondock Saints" showcasing the vigilante justice of two Irish brothers, and "Sin City" intertwining various stories of corruption and redemption in a noir-inspired metropolis. The visceral action, stylish visuals, and engaging storytelling in "Sin City" would certainly appeal to fans of The Boondock Saints' unconventional crime drama narrative.

John Wick (2014):

If you love the stellar performances of the vigilante antiheroes in "The Boondock Saints," you'll similarly enjoy Keanu Reeves in "John Wick". This movie is based on an ex-hitman who comes out of retirement to track down the gangsters that killed his dog, his late wife's last gift to him. The movie is rich with intense action sequences, symmetrical storytelling, and cinematography that is truly eye-catching.

Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels (1998):

Directed by Guy Ritchie, this British crime comedy is a wild ride filled with sharp wit and twists, similar to "The Boondock Saints." With a plethora of memorable characters and an intricate plot revolving around a high-stakes poker game, the film is a perfect blend of humor, action, and grit.

A History Of Violence (2005):

Directed by David Cronenberg, this crime-thriller examines how a person's past can haunt their present. It's about a humble family man with a secretive past who has to resort to a life of violence after his identity is exposed. Fans of "The Boondock Saints" may enjoy this movie for its exploration of moral complexity, gripping storyline, and strong performances.

The Town (2010):

Directed by Ben Affleck, "The Town" is a heist thriller that also delves into the lives of criminal siblings. The movie, set in Boston, explores the complications of balancing personal relationships with a life of crime. Fans of "The Boondock Saints" would probably appreciate the film's high-stakes drama and thematic similarities.



Like this? Then click here to see more crime movies